Skip to content

How to choose marketing help, and what to pay

Choose marketing help by the one result you need, not by the package: work out what that result is worth to you, pick the cheapest kind of help that can deliver it, and hire on a proposal that names the work, keeps the accounts in your name and lets you leave. Then check it every month against a written starting point.

Epica guide · Google documentation, agency surveys, Epica's research on small-business searches · November 2026

Look inside a proposal

What a marketing proposal tells you, and what it leaves out

An example of the kind of proposal a small business receives, taken apart. Hover a note to see the part it explains.

Proposal · monthly packageIllustrative example

What do I get for [$X] a month?

Our growth package includes:

  1. Optimization: ongoing optimization of your website
  2. Reporting: a monthly performance report
  3. Guarantee: first page on Google in 90 days

12-month agreement.

Missingtasks per monthsearches targetedwhose accountsad budget
  1. No tasks named. “Ongoing optimization” doesn't say what gets done. Ask for the monthly task list. Step 3
  2. A report, not a result. Ask which figures it reports: calls and leads, not only visits. Step 5
  3. A ranking promise. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. Cross this proposal off. Step 3
  4. Locked in. A year before any result. Ask for the minimum term and how you leave. Step 3
  5. The pattern: a good proposal names the work, the measure and the way out; a weak one names the promise.
60-second check · nothing is sent or stored

Are you ready to hire?

Answer eight questions. The diagram above and the five steps below reorder around your gaps.

  1. 01Can you say, as a number, the result you want: calls, bookings or leads a month?
  2. 02Do you know what one new customer earns you after costs?
  3. 03Do you know whether you need an agency, a freelancer or a tool for that result?
  4. 04Does the proposal list the tasks it will do each month?
  5. 05Does it show the agency fee and the ad budget as separate lines?
  6. 06Are your Search Console and Google Business Profile owned by your own Google account?
  7. 07Have you written down today's calls, leads and where you show up on Google?
  8. 08Do you know when, and by which figure, you'll judge whether it worked?
Tick steps as you go

Five steps

0 of 5 done · saved in this browser
  1. You know the one result you're paying for

    20 minutes · A website, Google Ads, the map and social media each fix a different problem, so the right help depends on where you lose customers.

    • Write the result you want as a number: calls a week, booked jobs or form leads a month.
    • Ask your last ten customers how they found you, and note the answers in their words.
    • Work out what one new customer earns you after costs. Times the extra customers you want, that is your monthly ceiling for fees and ad spend together.
    Go deeper
  2. You choose the kind of help that fits

    30 minutes · An agency, a freelancer, a tool and an AI agent cost different amounts of money and of your own time.

    • An agency covers several channels for the highest fee: in SparkToro's 2025 agency survey, 49% reported an average retainer of $1,000 to $5,000 a month.
    • A freelancer covers one channel for less: Ahrefs' survey of SEO providers found freelancers charging $1,348 a month on average, against $3,209 for agencies.
    • A tool or an AI agent costs least and runs on your time. If you serve one local area, Google says you can probably do much of the work yourself.
    Go deeper
  3. The proposal names the work, not a promise

    15 minutes per proposal · Google says it plainly: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.”

    • Ask for the tasks each month, line by line, and the searches the work will target.
    • Ask for the agency fee and the ad budget as two separate lines.
    • Cross off any proposal that guarantees a ranking or doesn't state the minimum term.
    Go deeper
  4. The accounts are yours, and the starting point is written down

    30 minutes · Without your own accounts and a dated starting point, no report can prove a result.

    • Open Search Console, your Google Business Profile and your analytics under a Google account you own, then add the provider as a user.
    • Write down today's calls and leads, and whether you show up on Google and ChatGPT for five customer searches.
    • If a provider wants to look before you hire, give it restricted, read-only access to Search Console.
    Go deeper
  5. You check the work every month

    15 minutes a month · A report shows what the provider chose to measure; your starting point shows what changed.

    • Compare calls, leads and booked jobs with your starting point, not visits or rankings alone.
    • Repeat the same five searches on Google and ChatGPT and note who is named.
    • Agree before you sign when you'll judge the result: Google says SEO usually needs four months to a year to show its benefit.
The research behind this guide

Google shows a map of agencies, not which one fits you

20 of 32results pages for choosing a marketing agency open with a map of nearby agencies
Searches US small businesses make to find a marketing agency. Purple: Google Maps' local pack on the page.
0 of 32of those pages show an AI Overview to help you compare
63 of 100searches for SEO help are already looking for a provider

Google answers this choice with a map of agencies near you and no summary, and most searches arrive ready to hire. A place on that map says where an agency is, not whether it fits your business: that's what the five steps check.

Epica research · searches by US small businesses for marketing help · October 2026

When you don't need this

If your calendar is full, don't hire marketing help yet: keep your Google Business Profile complete and ask every customer for a review. If you serve one small area, those two may be all the marketing you need.

Related questions

See all questions →

How we measure and write

The free Diagnosis: your starting point, done for you

See who Google and ChatGPT recommend today, before you pay anyone