Skip to content

How to choose an SEO company that won't promise first place

· 5 min read

How to choose an SEO company that won't promise first place

Choose an SEO company by interviewing three firms with Google's own questions and crossing off any firm that promises first place. First, put your Google accounts in your own name and write down where you stand today on five searches; that dated starting point lets you judge every later report.

If you paid the last firm for a year, got a traffic graph every month and still cannot say whether one job came from it, the gap was usually the first two moves. Nobody wrote down the starting point, and the accounts that held the record belonged to the agency.

Put the accounts in your name first

Three accounts hold the record of any SEO work: Google Search Console, your Google Business Profile and your analytics. Open each one under a Google account you own, then add the firm as a user later, so account ownership never moves when a contract ends.

In Search Console, add your site as a property and verify it with the DNS record or the HTML file it offers; your web host can add either in a few minutes. Check it worked under Settings, then Users and permissions: your own email should appear as the owner. Do the same check in your Business Profile under People and access.

Write down where you stand today

Pick five searches a customer types before calling you, each with your town or area, such as “emergency plumber Tampa” or “bookkeeper for contractors Austin”. For each one, note whether you appear on Google's first page, whether you show on the map, and whether ChatGPT and Gemini name you when you ask the same thing logged out.

That page, with today's date on it, is your dated baseline. Add the last three months of clicks from Search Console's Performance report, and you have what every later report gets compared with. Repeat the same five questions each month, the same way, because a single AI answer is one draw and proves nothing on its own.

Build a shortlist of three

There is no best SEO agency in the abstract, only the best fit for your five searches. Ask two owners in a neighboring trade who they use and what changed in their calls, look for firms whose past work you can see live, and treat directory listings and the map as a list of names, not a ranking of quality: the map tends to show whoever is closest.

Leave out anyone who found you first. Google tells owners to be wary of SEO firms, consultants and agencies that email out of the blue, and a cold pitch that promises page one is exactly that kind of email. A one-person SEO consultancy and a large firm both belong on the list if they pass the next step.

Interview them with Google's questions

Google's Search Central team keeps a short page, Do you need an SEO?, with the questions it suggests asking before you hire. They come from the company whose results you are paying to appear in, and they work on SEO firms of any size:

Google's question A useful answer
Can you show examples of previous work? Named clients you can call
Do you follow Google Search Essentials? Yes, and how they check your site
What results, in what timeframe, measured how? Your five searches against the baseline
What's your experience in my industry? Clients in your trade or a close one
What's your experience in my city? Local work, if you sell locally
How long have you been in business? A record you can verify
How will we communicate? One named contact, a fixed rhythm
Will you share every change you make? Yes, with the reason for each

The third question carries the weight. “More traffic” is not a measure; a firm that cannot name the searches it will work on has not looked at your market yet. Then call two of the clients it names and ask what changed in calls and forms, not in visits.

If a firm offers an audit before you hire, Google's advice is to grant read access to Search Console only at that stage, never write access. You keep control of the property while it looks.

Which promises should make you walk away?

No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.

Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO?

Rankings depend on what every competitor does and on how Google reads each search, and no outsider controls either. A guaranteed ranking is a sales line: the firm offering it is selling the promise, not the work. Ask for the tasks instead, and keep a hard look ready for these, all from the same Google page:

  • A claimed “special relationship” with Google, or a priority submit.
  • Talk of submitting your site to thousands of search engines.
  • A request that you link to the firm's own site; Google says you should never have to.
  • Secrecy about what the firm intends to do on your site.

Links are where the damage lasts longest. Google's spam policies define link spam as creating links “primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings”, buying them included, and warn that sites breaking those policies may rank lower or not appear in results at all. That penalty lands on your domain, not on the firm that bought the links.

Before you sign this week, search the contract for “guarantee”, “first page” and “#1”, and check that it names you as the owner of every account. A ranking promise in writing crosses the firm off; a missing ownership line gets added before you sign. If you would rather start from who Google and ChatGPT recommend for your searches today, the free analysis measures it from your own website.

When customers ask about what you do, who gets recommended?