Skip to content

How to pick a Black Friday promotion that keeps your margin

· 5 min read

How to pick a Black Friday promotion that keeps your margin

On Black Friday, the promotion that best protects your margin is usually a bundle or a gift with purchase, not a deep discount on your whole catalog. Before you choose, work out how many extra sales each option needs to leave you what a normal week does.

How many extra sales a discount needs

Run the numbers on one real product. Say you sell it for $100 and it costs you $60: each sale leaves you $40. If you sell 10 in a normal week, you earn $400, and that is the figure the promotion has to beat.

Black Friday price You keep per sale Sales to earn the same $400
$100 $40 10
$90 $30 14
$80 $20 20
$70 $10 40

Taking $20 off looks small on a sign, yet it means selling twice as many to stay even. Taking $30 off means four times as many, and few small shops quadruple their sales in one week. What decides it is your margin per sale, not the size of the discount.

Which promotion fits what you sell

Each format protects your margin in a different way. Pick one main promotion and at most one backup: three offers at once are more than a five second ad can explain.

Promotion When it works for you What can go wrong
Bundle of two or three products You sell things people use together The bundle gives away your best margin item
Gift with purchase You have an item that costs you little and customers value Giving it away with no minimum spend
Discount on a few products You have high margin items or stock to clear Stretching it across the whole catalog
Bonus card with a gift card Your customers buy holiday gifts Bonus cards redeemed on your busiest days

A bundle raises what each customer spends, and a gift with purchase costs you what you paid for the gift, not its shelf price. That is why both hold up better than a discount. If you do discount, put it on the products that earn you the most and leave out the ones that already sell well all year.

Gift cards come with a federal rule. A card a customer buys can't expire within five years under Regulation E's gift card rules, while a free bonus card handed out in a promotion falls outside them and can carry an earlier expiration date, printed on the card itself.

The “was” price you can show

A crossed out price has to be one you actually charged. The FTC's guides on former price comparisons put it this way:

If the former price is the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time, it provides a legitimate basis for the advertising of a price comparison.

FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, 16 CFR 233.1, eCFR

In practice, use the price the product sold at through October as the “was” price. Don't raise prices in early November to make the cut look bigger: the guide calls that kind of inflated price a false bargain.

What goes on the sign and the offer page

The sign is what shops look for most: “black friday sign” had 2,400 searches in the US in November 2025, by our count in the Google Ads Keyword Planner. A good sign fits in four lines: the promotion, the price next to the “was” price, the date it ends and how to buy.

The offer page, on your site or linked from Instagram, answers the questions people would otherwise call or text you about. Put them at the top, in your customers' words: how much, until when, what's included, how to pay, and whether you ship or offer pickup. One button to buy or book.

💡 Before you print it: show the sign for five seconds to someone who hasn't seen the offer and ask what they get and until when. If they can't say, the sign has too many words.

How to tell on Monday the 30th if it worked

Write down every day from November 23 to 30 how many promotion sales you made and what each one left you. Compare the total with what you earn in a normal week, not with revenue: a week with more orders and less money was a bad week.

Look at who bought, too. If almost every order came from regulars who would have bought in December anyway, you moved sales forward instead of winning customers. That difference tells you which promotion to repeat next year and which to drop.

If you'd rather spend that week selling in your store, we build and run your Black Friday campaign on Instagram and Facebook around the promotion you pick.

When customers ask about what you do, who gets recommended?